Here is a reader question about The Rewind Technique and Depersonalisation Disorder: Depersonalisation disorder seems to be something where a person copes with trauma by … Read More »The Rewind Technique: Dangers Of Disassociation?
In the video below, I help you work out what to do next when you are struggling to implement memory reconsolidation. In this video, I… Read More »When You Are Struggling To Implement Memory Reconsolidation
Elsewhere on this site, we have looked at what memory reconsolidation is and the steps needed for the brain to do it. We have looked… Read More »How To Check If Trauma Therapy Has Been Successful
In the imaginal protocol described in recent posts (and linked to below), the client has chosen a memory from their past that is representative of… Read More »How to be flexible and creative when working with trauma
So far we have laid the groundwork for the imaginal experience that is to come. We now have the feelings from the original event the… Read More »How To Guide The Therapy Session That Removes Trauma
From the previous two sessions, we now have the target feelings that we wish to replace, and the new responses that we will replace them… Read More »How to create reimagined Scenes That Remove trauma
In my last post, I described a process that gathers the trauma responses identified from an old, significant scene. In this article, I will show… Read More »How to generate feelings that mismatch trauma response
In this post, I want to dig deeper into the first session of my 4 part imaginal protocol, aimed at triggering memory reconsolidation. In this… Read More »Harvesting client feelings in trauma work
It took the young woman a good while and a lot of effort to climb thirty-five feet. There were several ladders, one after the other.… Read More »actively creating mismatches for trauma healing
Memory reconsolidation depends upon mismatch experiences inviting the brain to update old learning, including trauma responses. In this post, we will look at how to… Read More »How to use the imagination to erase trauma
Memory reconsolidation is a brain mechanism. It happens physiologically in the brain. Just as pupil dilation is a biological eye mechanism. Memory reconsolidation is not… Read More »Are You Aiming For Transformational Change In Therapy?
In this video and article, I show you how to follow nervous system responses. I will teach you how to reach an understanding of why… Read More »How to understand Safety with the movie question
Mismatches are key to giving the brain what it needs to overwrite trauma response. Would you like a tool that could reliably reveal mismatch information?… Read More »“What’s right with you?” – the tool to reliably reveal mismatches
Repetition of mismatch experiences is the key ingredient to removing trauma responses. But what does that mean, and how do we do it in practice?… Read More »The Role Of Repetition In Trauma Removal
In this post, I want to talk about the chronology of trauma. It’s an aspect that can sometimes be overlooked. When it comes to timelines,… Read More »The Importance of The Aftermath of traumatic events
In this post, I will take you through the 7 key questions from Mary and Bob Goulding. The Gouldings operated in the 70s and 80s.… Read More »7 Key Questions That Lead To Discovery With Your Therapy Clients
You can either watch the video below or read the article. So what happens if you’re working with a client and you want to help… Read More »Do we need to delve into history to erase trauma?
To trigger the brain’s in-built mechanism for change, it must have an experience of mismatch. An old prediction is broken. There is a lightbulb moment… Read More »The importance of experiential therapy work – and how to do it
A key task of therapists who seek to trigger memory reconsolidation is to help identify the client’s “target learning”. But what is meant by this… Read More »What do we mean by target learning in therapy?
Perfectionists are those who put pressure on themselves to be perfect. Good enough is not good enough. They experience the events of life as a… Read More »3 Ways to make sense of your perfectionist client
Do you have a client who finds it hard to just have fun without making themself pay for it somehow? Do they feel guilty whenever… Read More »Self-Punishing fun and enjoyment after abuse
In this article, I want to show how the lens of unmet needs is a powerful way to look at trauma and psychological injury. As… Read More »The healing power of meeting needs as a mismatch
There are many ways to trigger memory reconsolidation. It can happen conversationally, where the client bumps into a mismatch that causes a prediction error. It… Read More »The importance of autonomic spark in imaginal reenactments
When memory reconsolidation occurs, the change is transformational. The brain needs a mismatch experience that lands. It then needs the mismatch to be repeated. The… Read More »How to know if memory reconsolidation worked
Why do our clients experience the problems they do? Why do their problems keep recurring? Why don’t they simply change and get what they want? Why do they sometimes self sabotage their own progress? What can we do when our clients self-sabotage?
A core assumption is that the problem makes sense. Self-sabotage makes sense. Not changing makes sense. Our job is to discover how and why it makes sense. How can we understand what is happening for them and, more importantly, help them realise why this pattern keeps occurring?
The answer is important as it is likely the target learning that we will seek to remove through memory reconsolidation. Once this target is gone, the change becomes easy.
In this post, I will share a process that I use with many of my own clients. I call it The Single Sentence Technique. It allows me to get to the target learning, often as quickly as one session.
To understand how a client’s problem makes sense, I will look at 3 things:
- The solution to another problem
- How to discover the bigger problem
- An example case study for illustration
The SOLUTION TO ANOTHER PROBLEM
The client may feel crazy that they do this. They are not. They are perfectly rational. Their self-sabotage makes sense. Their problem makes sense.
Yes, it is a problem. But it is also the solution to a much bigger problem.
What would you prefer? A problem, or a bigger problem? We would all choose a problem instead of a bigger problem. That’s not craziness. That makes sense. It’s what every protection racket in history has relied upon.
Think of the gangster who tells the shopkeeper to give them $100 a week or they’ll be beaten and their store will be burned down. A hundred bucks a week is a problem. But it’s a problem they choose in order to prevent the bigger one.
Psychologically, this is standard. We make choices that make sense somehow. We choose one problem because it prevents an even bigger one. Our job as therapists is to first help the client realise what that bigger problem is.
We need to discover the underlying protection racket that is at work.
How to discover the bigger problem
There is a technique that comes from Motivational Interviewing that I repurpose in my practice. It helps me understand the truth of the client’s problem very quickly.
Motivational Interviewing asks the client 4 things:
- how does the status quo serve or benefit you?
- what are the costs of the status quo?
- what is the downside or price to be paid for changing?
- what are the benefits of changing?
The target learning that reproduces the problem is held in their answers to questions 1 and 3.
There will be a lot of information given here. Collect them in a list. Notice those that seem heavier or scarier.
Unpack answers that hint at something deeper. For instance, if the client says a benefit of keeping the problem means that they won’t have to feel happy, ask what would happen if they did feel happy. There needs to be some exploration to find the fear or problem.
Likewise, if the client says that a benefit of the problem is that things are easier somehow, find out what makes it easier. Ask what would be hard otherwise. Find the fear and the things that feel risky for them within their answers.
You can sum up the full reason for their problem in a statement. The kind I use is an adaptation of a statement structure taught by therapist, Niall Geoghegan. My version goes like this:
If I allow myself to get the thing I want
Then this terrible consequence (their answer from questions 1 and 3)
So I [insert problem]
Even though I long for it to go well
Because anything is better than the terrible consequence
Let’s apply the same logic to the protection racket mentioned earlier.
If I allow myself to keep all the money I earn
Then the gangster will burn my store down and violently attack me
So I pay him $100 every week
Even though I long to use that money to make my family’s lives better
Because anything is better than having my business destroyed and maybe even being killed by the gangster.
Crazy? Or does it make sense?
A CASE STUDY to illustrate
This case study is fictional for illustration purposes. Nonetheless, you will no doubt recognise some of your own clients in this depiction.
Stephen is a man in his 30s. As a child, his parents were overbearing and suffocating. He has grown up to become a successful professional. Yet romantic relationships have proven difficult. He has no problem attracting a partner, but he notices that he self-sabotages the moment things get closer.
When asked the Motivational Interviewing questions, he listed some benefits of keeping things as they are. He says he can maintain his own autonomy. He says it feels safer because he is able to keep some boundary between himself and others.
When asked what the cost would be if a magic wand could give him the closeness he wants, he notices a fear of losing himself in the relationship. He would cease to be himself and the other person would overwhelm him.
As such we could construct this sentence:
If I allow myself the love and closeness I crave
Then I will lose my identity and the other will take over me completely
So I do things that create distance and ensures the other moves away from me
Even though I long for love and closeness with them
Because anything is better than losing myself like I did to my parents.
Suddenly, this puzzle that had plagued him for so long was clarified. It made sense to him. When relationships got too close, his nervous system would become agitated.
He feared it would result in the same overbearing overwhelm and loss of self that he had experienced as a child. So he did something to sabotage the closeness in order to create some distance. It was no longer puzzling.
The problems our clients bring are not crazy. They makes sense. Like someone in the grip of a protection racket, it is both a problem AND a solution to a bigger problem. Stop paying the hundred bucks and life gets even worse than now. Protection rackets are a good metaphor because self-sabotage is a protection against something even worse.
We can repurpose the Motivational Interviewing questions to explore what the client is protecting themself from. As the client connects to the ways that staying the same serves them, they clarify what is happening for them. Likewise, as they explore the fears and dangers with getting what they want, they see why they ensure they don’t get it.
The problem not only makes sense, but the underlying protection is brought into awareness.
From there, you and the client both know the target learning to be changed. In Stephen’s case, his nervous system reacts to a loving partner as if they were his overwhelming parents. A bodily response to an old psychological injury is taking place.
We can use memory reconsolidation to overwrite those old responses that are no longer helpful today. This allows Stephen’s nervous system to assess his potential partners in the here and now. He can now feel safe with people who will not harm him. (See 3 steps to memory reconsolidation for more info.)
He finds that, after the work is complete, love and closeness is easy. The nervous system response that was causing him to panic and create distance is now gone. His nervous system is able to assess the true safety of this potential partner. If safe, he can allow himself the love and closeness he has always longed for. The problem is no longer required and so no longer occurs.
Don’t miss my next article, sign up below:
When I was training to be a therapist, my first trainer had a mantra about therapy. It stuck with me. He would say: “Therapy is… Read More »“Therapy is a process, not an event” – is IT true?
Many of our clients have histories that result in a felt loss of the ability to self protect. In this article, I want to look… Read More »How to invite trauma clients into self-protection with just one word
When a client has suffered from their problems for many years, it can sometimes feel a particular challenge to us as therapists. Every day, the… Read More »A new way to think of “deeply entrenched” trauma
In an earlier article, A 4 Step Road Map For Imaginal Re-Enactment Work, I outline an example process for imaginal work. It details one possible… Read More »In Imaginal Scenes, must the client reimagine the original people?
Are you working with someone who holds negative beliefs about themself? They suffer low self-esteem and tell themself “I’m not good enough?” The belief weaves… Read More »How to work with negative beliefs like “I’m not good enough”
Do you have anxious or depressed clients? Do you notice that they have a pattern of repressing their emotions? Do you try to coax them… Read More »Anxiety and depression: How to follow the lead of your client’s nervous system
Once you know about memory reconsolidation, it becomes a great gift. Yet it can also be a curse. You now know that there’s a brain… Read More »Can memory reconsolidation work give you burnout?
Mismatch experiences are the key to transformational change. These are the moments whereby old expectations are disconfirmed. The client has an experience of prediction error.… Read More »3 mismatches for transformational change in therapy
I want to show you a mesmerising film I saw on YouTube (see below). It has nothing to do with therapy. Yet it has everything… Read More »This movie unwittingly shows your client’s struggle
In this article, I will outline a case study showing the memory reconsolidation process in action. You will see that it created permanent change without… Read More »Case study: Darren keeps breaking down in tears
A common question that arises with trauma work relates to the timeframe of the work itself. Neuroscience lays out what the brain needs to trigger… Read More »Is there a time frame for successful trauma work?
Why do certain techniques and approaches work with trauma? How do they produce an outcome that is so transformational and quick that they seem miraculous?… Read More »The Rewind Technique and why it works – step by step
Are you racked with self doubt? Do you tell yourself that you’re a terrible therapist? Do you feel anxious and not good enough? Do you… Read More »Do you suffer from therapist imposter syndrome?
Memory reconsolidation is an exciting discovery given that it allows for the erasure of trauma responses. But are you put off by the fact that… Read More »Does memory reconsolidation restrict how you do therapy?
One of the ways I help trigger memory reconsolidation with clients is through imaginal reenactment. This involves reimagining a painful scene so that it goes… Read More »What if imagining new scenes results in grief or anger
The session ends, the client leaves and you feel sick to your stomach. You messed up. Your goal was to help but now look. You… Read More »How to handle making a blunder with your client
You’re seeing a client and you can’t figure out what disorder they have. You can see that they are struggling in areas of life. You… Read More »How do I figure out my client’s disorder, and do I really need to?
Do you ever have a client who gets it logically, but they don’t believe it? They cognitively understand the change needed, but things don’t change… Read More »When Clients Know It Logically, But They Don’t Believe It
Polyvagal theory, developed by Stephen Porges, is an explanation of what happens with the nervous system when faced with safety or threat. He describes how… Read More »How to use polyvagal theory in the therapy room
What can we do when our clients self-sabotage? We see them making progress towards their goals and then it’s like they hit a self destruct… Read More »Why does your client self-sabotage their success?
What if you felt confident and at ease no matter what your client brought to you? What if you knew exactly what you need to… Read More »A 4 Step road map for imaginal re-enactment work
What if you have a client whose main difficulty comes from the very relationships they crave? Their life may seem pretty together, but relationships are… Read More »How to help your client finally have a fulfilling relationship
You’ve completed your studies. You’re working with clients. And you’re burning out. Not only is the workload heavy. But worse, you feel like you know… Read More »Feel like you still know nothing but have no time to learn more? try this
Memory reconsolidation is the only known brain mechanism that results in transformational change. Transformational change is the kind that is permanent and effortless to maintain.… Read More »What are the 3 steps to memory reconsolidation?
Are you a therapist who has a real desire to do trauma work, especially complex trauma? Are you feeling confused about which modality works best… Read More »Overwhelmed by which therapy to use for trauma?
In this article, I will show you why feelings are so important to transformational change. I will show you how to identify the responses to… Read More »What feelings need to change to overwrite trauma?
You have done great work with your trauma clients. Their lives improved and they no longer need your help. For each client that moved on,… Read More »Is covid bringing back your ‘healed’ trauma clients?
One of the more common presentations in therapy is a client suffering from anxiety. You will see anxiety so often as a therapist. Sometimes it… Read More »What is the best therapy approach for anxiety?
Your client wants to find more meaning in life. They have a yearning for a life of greater purpose. Yet they struggle to identify what… Read More »10 ways to help clients find meaning in life
Do you find yourself struggling whenever a client says they have had a good week? Do you panic a little and think “so what will… Read More »What to do when your client has had a good week?
Do you ever feel stuck with a client? Are you working hard on what the client wants to change but find that the suffering continues… Read More »How To Find Your Client’s True Target Of Change
Your client has low motivation. It’s difficult because they don’t feel like doing anything. Any attempts to improve life go nowhere because they don’t feel… Read More »Does your client want to be more motivated?
What happens when you’re giving therapy, and the person opposite has the exact same problem that you do? They mention thoughts and feelings that you… Read More »What if your client has the problem you have?